East Aurora, NY, may be best known for its small-town charm, arts-and-crafts history, and cozy boutiques—but in recent years, it has quietly become a must-visit destination for Mexican food lovers. Whether you're craving a quick taco on the go or looking for a sit-down dinner with handcrafted margaritas, this charming Western New York town has a growing selection of authentic and beloved Mexican restaurants that are winning the hearts—and appetites—of locals and visitors alike.
This guide takes you through the most loved Mexican restaurants in East Aurora, according to those who know the town best: the locals.
🌮 1. Arriba Tortilla – A Fiesta of Fresh Flavor
Ask anyone in town where to go for the best tacos, and you’ll likely hear “Arriba Tortilla†without hesitation. Known for its colorful interior, friendly vibes, and made-from-scratch menu, this local favorite serves up an impressive variety of tacos, burritos, and bowls.
Must-try: The grilled chicken tacos with smoky chipotle aioli, paired with one of their famous margarita flights.
Local tip: Go on Taco Tuesday for deals and a lively atmosphere.
🌯 2. El Agave – Family Recipes with a Heartfelt Touch
A hidden gem tucked off the main road, El Agave is beloved for its home-style cooking and cozy atmosphere. Run by a family with deep roots in traditional Mexican cuisine, every dish here feels like a meal prepared with love.
Must-try: Their molé poblano chicken—a rich, savory sauce with subtle sweetness that locals swear by.
Local tip: Don’t skip the tableside guacamole—custom-made to your spice preference.
🹠3. Las Puertas Taqueria – Upscale Meets Authentic
For a more modern dining experience, Las Puertas Taqueria offers chef-driven Mexican cuisine with bold presentations and seasonal ingredients. Think of it as fine dining meets fiesta. The restaurant brings a sophisticated twist to traditional dishes without sacrificing authenticity.
Must-try: Duck carnitas tacos and the mezcal old fashioned for a smoky-smooth cocktail pairing.
Local tip: Ideal for date nights and special occasions—make a reservation on weekends.
🧀 4. Cantina Local – Casual Eats with Big Flavor
A Restaurant newer addition to the East Aurora food scene, Cantina Local has quickly become popular for its laid-back atmosphere, fast service, and customizable menu. It’s the perfect stop for a casual lunch or quick bite on the go.
Must-try: The quesabirria tacos—cheesy, juicy, and served with flavorful consommé for dipping.
Local tip: Their takeout is top-notch—order ahead for an easy weeknight dinner fix.
🥑 Why Locals Keep Coming Back
What makes East Aurora’s Mexican restaurants so beloved isn’t just the food—it’s the authenticity, community spirit, and creativity behind each kitchen. These are places where:
The staff remembers your name.
The recipes are often passed down through generations.
The experience is just as memorable as the meal.
In a town where tradition meets innovation, Mexican cuisine has found a home—one taco, enchilada, and margarita at a time.
Final Bite: A Small Town with Big Flavor
If you’re looking to taste the heart and soul of Mexico without leaving Western New York, East Aurora has you covered. Whether you’re a lifelong local or a first-time visitor, exploring these locally loved Mexican eateries is a flavorful journey you won’t forget.